If there was ever a time to re-engage my blog, now is it.
Since early June, I have been reading and hearing so much
misinformation regarding the WMHS Pediatric Unit. We are NOT abandoning children by closing our
Pediatrics Unit. The term “closing” is a
regulatory term that we have to use even if we are transitioning our unit from
virtually a single Pediatric inpatient bed on an adult patient unit to a five
bed Pediatric Observation Unit adjacent to the Emergency Department. Unfortunately, last Saturday’s newspaper
headline stated that the unit was closing.
If you just read the headline and not the article, I can see how one
would think that the Pediatric unit was actually closing, but again, that is
not the case.
Beginning in early
August 2018, any child requiring an overnight stay will be cared for in a dedicated,
secure unit that is being newly constructed next to the ED. The child can remain in the unit up to 48
hours; after that, clinical decisions will be made as to transfer or discharge
to home. This unit will be staffed by
Pediatric Advanced Life Support trained nurses along with Emergency Department
physicians and physician assistants. Pediatricians
will continue to attend to children in the unit, as well. Because we have so few pediatric patients (for
the first nine months of the fiscal year, we have admitted 44 children who have
stayed an average of 1.93 days), our Pediatric staff nurses cannot maintain
their expertise, nor can we recruit dedicated Pediatric nurses because we admit
so few children. The ED staff are very
well trained in caring for and treating both adults and children. In fact, last year we treated close to 9,500
Pediatric patients in the Emergency Department with 86 being admitted to WMHS
and about 300 being transferred to a Pediatric Specialty hospital due to their
chronic or critical condition. As a
parent and a grandparent, I can’t imagine why a parent or guardian wouldn’t want
their very ill child treated in a specialty facility where the specialists
treat thousands of children each year.
Some have said just bring the specialists to Cumberland and
we do, but caring for children on an outpatient basis usually for chronic or
follow up care in Pediatric Cardiology and Neurology. With a two hour travel distance and so few
patients, it is unrealistic to think that specialists would come to Cumberland
to perform surgery on one child. There
are physician shortages in virtually every specialty for both adults and
children and areas such as ours have the greatest challenges in recruiting. WMHS like so many other community hospitals have
had to resort to alternatives in the care and treatment of children. We are using more digital technology,
telemedicine, and partnerships to address the needs of children and through our
affiliation with UPMC, these advancements will continue to grow. In Maryland, 33 out of the 47 hospitals, have
Pediatric Units. Eighteen of those
hospitals have a length of stay for Pediatrics of less than a day and there are
nine Maryland hospitals similar to WMHS with a length of stay of less than two
days. Over the last 30 years, Pediatric
beds in Maryland have decreased by more than half from 882 to 385. More and more children are being cared for in
the most appropriate location, a specialty hospital, when they have a critical
or chronic condition.
I certainly recognize the hardship for families who have to
travel out of the area if their child is very ill. Our staff at WMHS will work with the
specialty hospital as well as throughout our community to assist with this
hardship to the extent possible.
Although such transfers have been occurring for the last several years,
we will become more engaged in the process and assist these families in
navigating the challenges that they face when such circumstances arise.
I hope that the information contained within this blog helps
to clarify the circumstances surrounding Pediatrics at WMHS.
In all due respect, this is nothing more than spin by WMHS. You criticize the newspaper for their headline about the Pediatric Unit closing. The fact is that you have closed the Pediatric unit years ago. But, you are arguing over the word “closing”. You, yourself said, “the term closing is a regulatory term that we have to use”. You have to use it because it is fact! You will not be admitting Pediatric patients to the pediatric unit because it is closed. You instead will be “transferring “ pediatric patients to the observation unit. Just because it is new and cost millions of dollars does not mean that it is what is best for this community.
ReplyDeleteWMHS has been using the following statistics to reinforce their decision for an observation unit. According to your numbers, 9500 children have been seen by ED. 86 were admitted to the hospital and few of those stayed more than 48 hours. 300 were “transferred “ to another hospital for chronic or critical conditions. The number that you neglect to report is how many your ED referred to another hospital. The original Pediatric Unit has been closed for years. What effect does that have on your statistics? According to your own blog, “ transfers have been occurring for the last several years”. Your data is scewed because your hospital has not fully served children for years. Families have been sent out of town for broken bones, dehydration, and other minor illnesses that used to be handled in our hometown. Your data may serve your spin but does not show the full story.
You also say that you recognize the hardship to families. Do you know that MA children will not be able to receive care for more than 24 hours? Please review this document from MDH.
https://mmcp.health.maryland.gov/MCOupdates/Documents/pt_30-17.pdf
If children with MA stay in your observation unit over the 24 hour period, their family will be charged out-of-network for the additional time in the hospital. That means that families who live in poverty will have even less care for their children who are in the most need.
Lastly, on June 14 your staff was asked how they plan to help families who have to go out of town and have many needs. Your staff stated that once they helped the families to get to the receiving hospital, it was that hospitals responsibility to help that family. When I met with Mr. Karstetter I asked if they have worked with local agencies to help prepare for family ‘s needs. His response was something to the effect of that the hospital can’t do everything. So, how exactly is WMHS going to be more engaged in the process? I have contacted the County Commissioners to request their help to get community agencies together to help families during their medical crisis.
Every parent wants the very best care for their child. Chronic and critical illness is an excellent reason to transfer a child. But, please explain to families why WMHS refers their child to another hospital for common childhood illnesses. This means they need to pay for transportation, hotel, food and possible loss of income.
WMHS’s decision is not taking into consideration the community. Very sad!